General
James Rudolph Garfield, Secretary of the Interior, Plaintiff in Error, v. The United States ex rel. Benjamin F. Vaughan, Guardian, etc.; James Rudolph Garfield, Secretary of the Interior, Plaintiff in Error, v. The United States ex rel. Edward A. Vaughan; James Rudolph Garfield, Secretary of the Interior, Plaintiff in Error, v. The United States ex rel. Benjamin F. Vaughan; and James Rudolph Garfield, Secretary of the Interior, Plaintiff in Error, v. The United States ex rel. Ambrose L. Rice
212 U.S. 589·Supreme Court of the United States·1909
Brief incoming
Hand-reviewed Bluebook brief (procedural posture, facts, issue, holding, reasoning, dissent) ships once the AI generation pipeline runs through this case. Join the waitlist to get notified when 1L briefs go live.
Opinion
No. 371.
James Rudolph Garfield, Secretary of the Interior, Plaintiff in Error, v. The United States ex rel. Benjamin F. Vaughan, Guardian, etc.; James Rudolph Garfield, Secretary of the Interior, Plaintiff in Error, v. The United States ex rel. Edward A. Vaughan; James Rudolph Garfield, Secretary of the Interior, Plaintiff in Error, v. The United States ex rel. Benjamin F. Vaughan; and James Rudolph Garfield, Secretary of the Interior, Plaintiff in Error, v. The United States ex rel. Ambrose L. Rice.
No. 372.
No. 373.
No. 374.
[MAJORITY]
In error to the Court of Appeals of the District of Columbia. January 18, 1909. Dismissed with costs on motion of Mr. Solicitor General Hoyt for the plaintiff in error. The Attorney General for plaintiff in error. Mr. Charles J. Kappler, Mr: Charles H. Merillat, Mr. James K. Jones and Mr. Charles M: Fechheimer for defendants in error in Nos. 371, 372 and 373. No appearance for defendant in error in No. 374.