Price v. Cargin and Cargin

Price v. Cargin and Cargin Collection Supreme Court Judgments Date 1957-03-27 Report [1957] SCR 341 Judges Kerwin, Patrick; Rand, Ivan Cleveland; Locke, Charles Holland; Cartwright, John Robert; Fauteux, Joseph Honoré Gérald On appeal from Ontario Subjects Family law Decision Content Supreme Court of Canada Price v. Cargin and Cargin, [1957] S.C.R. 341 Date: 1957-03-27 Price and Cargin and Cargin 1957: March 27. Infants—Custody—Welfare of child—Award of custody to strangers in blood rather than to father. APPEAL from a judgment of the Court of Appeal for Ontario (1) affirming the judgment of Barlow J. George T. Walsh, Jr., and George H. Davies, for the appellant. John Mirsky, Q.C., for the respondents. The judgment of the Court was delivered by THE CHIEF JUSTICE (orally):—Mr. Mirsky, it is unnecessary for us to call upon you. Mr. Walsh and Mr. Davies have said everything possible on behalf of the appellant, but we are unable to disagree with the result arrived at by the two Courts below. The appeal is, therefore, dismissed with costs, but there will be no costs of the motion for leave to appeal. Appeal dismissed with costs. Solicitor for the plaintiff, appellant: George H. Davies, Toronto. Solicitor for the defendants, respondents: J.C.M. German, Cobourg. …