White v. Parker

White v. Parker
Collection
Supreme Court Judgments
Date
1889-10-26
Report
(1889) 16 SCR 699
Judges
Ritchie, William Johnstone; Strong, Samuel Henry; Patterson, Christopher Salmon; Taschereau, Henri-Elzéar; Gwynne, John Wellington
On appeal from
New Brunswick
Subjects
Appeal
Decision Content
Supreme Court of Canada
White v. Parker (1889) 16 SCR 699
Date: 1889-10-26
Beverly White (Defendant)
Appellant
And
Maria Parker, Administratrix of the Estate and Effects of David M. Parker, deceased (Plaintiff)
Respondent.
1889: Oct. 26.
Present: Sir W. J. Ritchie C.J. and Strong, Taschereau, Gwynne and Patterson JJ.
ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW BRUNSWICK.
Appeal—New trial—Abatement of action—Death of plaintiff—Actio personalis moritur cum persona—Railway accident—Lord Campbell's act.
P. brought an action against a conductor of the I.C.R. for injuries received in attempting to board a train and alleged to be caused by the negligence of the conductor in not bringing the train to a stand still. On the trial P. was non-suited and on motion to the full court the non-suit was set aside and a new trial ordered. Between the verdict and the judgment ordering a new trial P. died and a suggestion of his death was entered on the record. On appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada from the order of the full court:
Held, that under Lord Campbell's Act, or the equivalent statute in New Brunswick (C.S. N.B. ch. 86) an entirely new cause of action arose on the death of P. and the original action was entirely gone and could not be revived.
There being no cause before the court the appeal was quashed without costs.