Ibrahim v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration)

Ibrahim v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration)
Court (s) Database
Federal Court Decisions
Date
2020-04-29
Neutral citation
2020 FC 558
File numbers
IMM-5304-19
Decision Content
Date: 20200429
Docket: IMM-5304-19
CITATION: 2020 FC 558
Ottawa, Ontario, April 29, 2020
PRESENT: The Honourable Justice Annis
BETWEEN:
AHMED ABDALMOTLIB ABDALHAFIZ IBRAHIM
Applicant
and
THE MINISTER OF CITIZENSHIP AND IMMIGRATION
ORDER
[1] This matter was scheduled for judicial review to be heard on March 25, 2020. It concerns allegations of professional incompetence, negligence, or other conduct against the Applicant’s former legal counsel, Mr. Jamal Addine Fraygui.
[2] By way of a notice of motion filed March 2, 2020, the Applicant’s former counsel sought leave to intervene to introduce certain documents pursuant to Rule 109, 364(2) and 369 of the Federal Court Rules. The Applicant filed submissions contesting the request to intervene. The Respondent in turn filed submissions supporting the former legal counsel’s motion to intervene.
[3] The documents sought to be introduced by intervention concern correspondence between the former counsel and the Barreau du Québec, which dismissed the Applicant’s complaint against him.
[4] The Applicant contends that the written materials will not assist the Court in the determination of this matter. He also argues that the information was available to the Court before it granted leave. The Respondent and intervener contest these submissions by their replies.
[5] There are issues whether the Protocol for Allegations Against Counsel of this Court have been complied with. The documents sought to be added to the record appear relevant. In any event, this is a determination that should be made by the Court hearing the judicial review.
[6] The request to intervene also appears to be in compliance with the factors supporting an intervention described in the Canadian Union of Public Employees v Canadian Airlines International Ltd., 2000 FCA 233 at para 8, and Canadian Pacific Railway v Boutique Jacob Inc, 2006 FCA 426 at para 21.
[7] Accordingly, permission is granted to the Intervener to file the requested materials that will form part of the record in the hearing the pending judicial review.
ORDER in IMM-5304-19 is:
The Court orders that Mr. Jamal Addine Fraygui is granted leave to intervene for the purpose of filing the documents in Exhibit “A” in the Notice of Motion and the Written Representations of his Counsel, Mr. Giuseppe DiDonato, to form part of the record in the judicial review of this matter.
Ank
“Peter Annis”
Blank
Judge
FEDERAL COURT
SOLICITORS OF RECORD
Docket:
IMM-5304-19
STYLE OF CAUSE:
AHMED ABDALMOTLIB ABDALHAFIZ IBRAHIM v THE MINISTER OF CITIZENSHIP AND IMMIGRATION
MOTION IN WRITING CONSIDERED AT OTTAWA, ONTARIO PURSUANT TO RULE 369 OF THE FEDERAL COURTS RULES
ORDER AND REASONS
JUSTICE ANNIS
DATED:
April 29, 2020
APPEARANCES:
Jacqueline Ozor
FOR THE APPLICANT
Giuseppe Di Donator
FOR THE INTERVENOR
Nadine Silverman
For the respondent
SOLICITORS OF RECORD:
Jacqueline Ozor
FOR THE APPLICANT
Giuseppe Di Donator
FOR THE INTERVENOR
Nadine Silverman
Attorney General of Canada
For the respondent