Wagner v. Canada

Wagner v. Canada
Court (s) Database
Federal Court of Appeal Decisions
Date
2001-10-23
Neutral citation
2001 FCA 319
File numbers
A-485-97
Decision Content
Date: 20011023
Docket: A-485-97
A-486-97
A-487-97
A-488-97
Neutral citation: 2001 FCA 319
CORAM: DESJARDINS J.A.
DÉCARYJ.A.
NOËL J.A.
BETWEEN:
DANIEL WAGNER
GABRIEL BORDELEAU
RAYMOND ÉLIAS
AND
CLINIQUE MÉDICALE DE ROCK-FOREST INC.
Appellants
and
HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN
Respondent
Hearing held at Montréal, Quebec, on October 23, 2001
Judgment delivered from the bench at Montréal, Quebec, on October 23, 2001
Date: 20011023
Docket: A-485-97
A-486-97
A-487-97
A-488-97
Neutral citation: 2001 FCA 319
CORAM: DESJARDINS J.A.
DÉCARY J.A.
NOËL J.A.
BETWEEN:
DANIEL WAGNER
GABRIEL BORDELEAU
RAYMOND ÉLIAS
AND
CLINIQUE MÉDICALE DE ROCK-FOREST INC.
Appellants
and
HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN
Respondent
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
(Delivered from the bench at Montréal, Quebec
on October 23, 2001)
NOËL J.A.
[1] These are four appeals from a decision by Judge Garon (as he then was) of the Tax Court of Canada dismissing the appellants' appeals in part ([1997] T.C.J. No. 86). These reasons dispose of the four appeals.
[2] In our opinion, these appeals cannot succeed. With respect to the first issue raised, the date of the transaction, we believe that the sale of the property in question took place on June 16, 1987, when the deed of sale was executed, for tax purposes and under the applicable civil law.
[3] On that point, it seems obvious that the resolution of October 7, 1986, did not operate as a deed conveying property and that neither the shareholders nor the Rock-Forest Inc. medical clinic gave it that effect. This is clearly apparent from the income tax returns filed by the parties, which, without exception, reported the purchase and sale of the property in the 1987 calendar year.
[4] The position taken by the parties in their respective income tax returns is furthermore completely consistent with the evidence. For example, the undivided partnership, which, according to the resolution, had to be set up in order to purchase the property, was created only on June 1, 1987; the clinic's financial statements for its fiscal year ending February 28, 1987, still show the property as an asset; the clinic had furthermore claimed the expenses incurred with respect to the property up to the date of the deed of sale, and the adjustments for municipal and school taxes, rents, and mortgage payments were also made on that date.
[5] The parties' position that the transaction took place on a date other than the date on which the deed of sale was signed is not based on any objective evidence and must be rejected.
[6] With respect to the second issue in the appeal, we are of the opinion that the trial judge could have concluded from the facts that the parties to the sale had not intended to make the transaction at the fair market value and that therefore they could not rely on the price adjustment clause that was included in the contract.
[7] The appeals will be dismissed with costs.
"Marc Noël"
J.A.
Certified true translation
Sophie Debbané, LL.B.
FEDERAL COURT OF APPEAL
Date: 20011023
Docket: A-485-97
A-486-97
A-487-97
A-488-97
Between:
DANIEL WAGNER
GABRIEL BORDELEAU
RAYMOND ÉLIAS
AND
CLINIQUE MÉDICALE DE ROCK-FOREST INC.
Appellants
and
HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN
Respondent
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT OF
THE COURT
FEDERAL COURT OF APPEAL
NAMES OF COUNSEL AND SOLICITORS OF RECORD
DOCKET: A-485-97 / A-486-97 / A-487-97 / A-488-97
STYLE OF CAUSE: DANIEL WAGNER ET AL.
Appellants
and
HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN
Respondent
PLACE OF HEARING: Montréal, Quebec
DATE OF HEARING: October 23, 2001
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT OF THE COURT OF THE HONOURABLE NOËL J.A.
DATED: October 23, 2001
APPEARANCES:
Richard Wagner FOR THE APPELLANTS
(Daniel Wagner, Gabriel Bordeleau and Clinique médicale Rock-Forest Inc.)
Luc Borduas/Philippe Bureau FOR THE APPELLANT
(Raymond Élias)
Nathalie Labbé FOR THE RESPONDENT
SOLICITORS OF RECORD:
Lavery de Billy FOR THE APPELLANTS
Montréal, Quebec (Daniel Wagner, Gabriel Bordeleau and Clinique médicale Rock-Forest Inc.)
Demers Bureau Borduas FOR THE APPELLANT
Montréal, Quebec (Raymond Élias)
Morris Rosenberg
Deputy Attorney General of Canada
Montréal, Quebec FOR THE RESPONDENT
Date: 20011023
Docket: A-485-97
Montréal, Quebec, October 23, 2001
Coram: DESJARDINS J.A.
DÉCARY J.A.
NOËL J.A.
BETWEEN:
DANIEL WAGNER
Appellant
and
HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN
Respondent
JUDGMENT
This appeal is dismissed with costs.
"Alice Desjardins"
J.A.
Certified true translation
Sophie Debbané, LL.B.
Date: 20011023
Docket: A-486-97
Montréal, Quebec, October 23, 2001
Coram: DESJARDINS J.A.
DÉCARY J.A.
NOËL J.A.
BETWEEN:
GABRIEL BORDELEAU
Appellant
and
HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN
Respondent
JUDGMENT
This appeal is dismissed with costs.
"Alice Desjardins"
J.A.
Certified true translation
Sophie Debbané, LL.B.
Date: 20011023
Docket: A-487-97
Montréal, Quebec, October 23, 2001
Coram: DESJARDINS J.A.
DÉCARY J.A.
NOËL J.A.
BETWEEN:
RAYMOND ELIAS
Appellant
and
HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN
Respondent
JUDGMENT
This appeal is dismissed with costs.
"Alice Desjardins"
J.A.
Certified true translation
Sophie Debbané, LL.B.
Date: 20011023
Docket: A-488-97
Montréal, Quebec, October 23, 2001
Coram: DESJARDINS J.A.
DECARY J.A.
NOËL J.A.
BETWEEN:
CLINIQUE MÉDICALE DE ROCK FOREST INC.
Appellant
and
HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN
Respondent
JUDGMENT
This appeal is dismissed with costs.
"Alice Desjardins"
J.A.
Certified true translation
Sophie Debbané, LL.B.