Pierrot v. Canada

Pierrot v. Canada
Court (s) Database
Federal Court Decisions
Date
2023-01-10
Neutral citation
2023 FC 36
File numbers
T-142-22
Decision Content
Date: 20230110
Docket: T-142-22
Citation: 2023 FC 36
Ottawa, Ontario, January 10, 2023
PRESENT: The Honourable Mr. Justice Zinn
PROPOSED CLASS PROCEEDING
BETWEEN:
HARVEY ADAM PIERROT
Plaintiff
and
HIS MAJESTY THE KING
Defendant
ORDER AND REASONS
[1] Canada moves to stay this proceeding [Pierrot] on the basis that the claims asserted fall within two certified class actions: Greenwood and Gray v His Majesty the King (Federal Court File T-1201-18) [Greenwood] and Association des membres de la police montée du Québec Inc et al v His Majesty the King (Québec Superior Court File 500-06-000820-163) [AMPMQ]. In addition, it submits that Pierrot is entirely duplicative of the proposed class action in Hudson v The King (Federal Court File T-723-20) [Hudson].
[2] This motion was heard immediately following the hearing of Canada’s motion in Hudson seeking an order staying it on the basis that the claims asserted fall within two certified class actions: Greenwood and AMPMQ. Many of the submissions made on this motion were also made on the Hudson motion.
[3] Paragraph 2 of the Amended Statement of Claim in Hudson describes the nature of that action as follows:
This action concerns systemic racism in the Royal Canadian Mounted Police (“RCMP”) on the basis of race, national or ethnic origin, colour or religion directed at racialized individuals who work for or with the RCMP.
[4] Paragraph 2 of the Statement of Claim in Pierrot describes the nature of this action as follows:
This action concerns systemic racism within the Royal Canadian Mounted Police (the “RCMP”). As a consequence of this systemic racism, Indigenous RCMP members (including regular members, civilian members, and special constable members) and reservists (collectively, “RCMP Members and Reservists”) were subjected to racism and race-based harassment and discrimination in the RCMP workplace and were treated differently than non-indigenous RCMP Members and Reservists.
[5] Both Hudson and Pierrot base the action on systemic racism whereas, as is described in the Reasons for dismissing the motion for a stay in Hudson, Greenwood and AMPMQ appear to address acts of direct and overt discrimination.
[6] For the reasons issued in Hudson v Canada, 2023 FC 35, dismissing the Hudson motion for a stay, this motion for a stay based on the proceedings in Greenwood and AMPMQ, will likewise be dismissed.
[7] Canada’s motion to stay Pierrot on the basis that it asserts an identical cause of action to Hudson is more compelling. However, at the hearing of this motion, counsel for Mr. Pierrot agreed that his action would be held in abeyance pending a final determination in Hudson. There was no objection noted from Canada to issuing a stay pending a final determination in Hudson, and it shall be so ordered.
[8] Accordingly, Canada’s motion to stay Pierrot is allowed, but the order staying this action is limited to a stay pending a final determination in Hudson.
ORDER in T-142-22
THIS COURT ORDERS that in accordance with these Reasons, Canada’s motion is allowed in part and this action is stayed pending a final determination in Hudson.
"Russel W. Zinn"
Judge
FEDERAL COURT
SOLICITORS OF RECORD
DOCKET:
T-142-22
STYLE OF CAUSE:
HARVEY ADAM PIERROT v HIS MAJESTY THE KING
PLACE OF HEARING:
VANCOUVER, BRITISH COLUMBIA
DATE OF HEARING:
October 4, 2022
ORDER AND REASONS:
ZINN J.
DATED:
january 10, 2023
APPEARANCES:
David Klein Aden Klein Angela Bespflug Steven L. Cooper, K.C. Maria Grzybowska
For The Plaintiff
Christine Mohr
Jacob Pollice Marilyn Venney
For The Defendant
SOLICITORS OF RECORD:
Klein Lawyers LLP Barristers and Solicitors Vancouver, British Columbia Klein Avocats Plaideurs Inc
Barristers and Solicitors
Montreal, Quebec
Murphy Battista LLP Barristers and Solicitors Vancouver, British Columbia
For The Plaintiff
Cooper Regel LLP Barristers and Solicitors Sherwood Park, Alberta
Attorney General of Canada Toronto, Ontario
For The Defendant