IA196582013 & Ors.

For the Respondent: Miss Brocklesby-Weller, Senior Home Office Presenting Officer

The appellants are citizens of Pakistan. The first appellant is the wife of the second appellant and the third and fourth appellants are their children. I shall hereafter refer to the �first appellant� as �the appellant� as it is her application for leave to remain as a Tier 1 (Entrepreneur) Migrant which is the subject of this appeal. The other appellants are her dependants.

The appellant�s application was refused by the Secretary of State in a decision which is dated 7 May 2013. She appealed to the First-tier Tribunal (Judge Napthine) which, in a determination promulgated on 17 March 2014, dismissed the appeals. The appellant now appeals, with permission, to the Upper Tribunal.

The first hearing of this appeal at Field House took place on 24 June 2014 before His Honour Judge Haddon-Cave and Upper Tribunal Judge Clive Lane. On that occasion, the hearing was adjourned. It was then listed before Upper Tribunal Judge Clive Lane alone on 30 April 2015. At the first hearing, Mr Naseem of Counsel appeared for the appellants. At the hearing on 30 April 2015, the appellants were represented by Mr S Ahmed of Counsel. Miss A Brocklesby-Weller, a Senior Home Office Presenting Officer, appeared for the respondent on the second occasion.

Following the hearing on 30 April 2015, I invited the parties to submit further submissions in writing regarding the Secretary of State�s guidance for entrepreneur migrant applicants. I did not receive any submissions from the appellants and Miss Brocklesby-Weller informed me by email that she did not, in the circumstances, seek to make any further representations. I have therefore determined the appeal.