IA100092015 & IA100152015

The appellants appeal against the decision of First-tier Tribunal Judge Pacey promulgated 3.8.15, dismissing their appeals against the decisions of the Secretary of State, dated 24.2.15, to refuse their applications for leave to remain in the UK on human rights grounds and to remove them from the UK pursuant to section 47 of the Immigration Asylum and Nationality Act 2006. The Judge heard the appeal on 23.7.15.

For the reasons set out below I find no material error of law in the making of the decision of the First-tier Tribunal such as to require the decision of Judge Pacey to be set aside.

The grounds of appeal are rather confused and difficult to follow. I also found Mr Talacchi's submissions rather difficult to follow as they did not seem to relate directly to the issues in the appeal. In particular, I fail to understand in what way it is submitted that the First-tier Tribunal Judge made "unreasonable credibility findings." In granting permission on a different ground, Judge Molloy refused permission to appeal on this ground and it need not be taken further.

Judge Molloy also refused permission in relation to the ground challenging, on grounds of failure to provide sufficient reasons, the finding at �12 of the decision that the appellants did not meet the requirements of Appendix FM, for the reasons set out in the Secretary of State's refusal decision.

It is perhaps important to understand the background and recall the nature of the application made to the Secretary of State on 30.12.14.