Roy v. Calgary Airport Authority

Roy v. Calgary Airport Authority
Court (s) Database
Federal Court Decisions
Date
2020-11-30
Neutral citation
2020 FC 1105
File numbers
T-519-19
Notes
A correction was made on December 8, 2020.
Decision Content
Date: 20201130
Docket: T-519-19
Citation: 2020 FC 1105
Vancouver, British Columbia, November 30, 2020
PRESENT: The Honourable Madam Justice McVeigh
PROPOSED CLASS ACTION
BETWEEN:
BRIAN ROY
Plaintiff
and
THE CALGARY AIRPORT AUTHORITY
EDMONTON REGIONAL AIRPORTS AUTHORITY
FORT MCMURRAY AIRPORT AUTHORITY
GRANDE PRAIRIE AIRPORT COMMISSION
COMOX VALLEY AIRPORT COMMISSION
NORTH PEACE AIRPORT SERVICES LTD.
KAMLOOPS AIRPORT AUTHORITY SOCIETY
KAMLOOPS AIRPORT LTD.
PRINCE GEORGE AIRPORT AUTHORITY INC.
VANCOUVER AIRPORT AUTHORITY
VICTORIA AIRPORT AUTHORITY
WINNIPEG AIRPORTS AUTHORITY INC.
GREATER MONCTON INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT AUTHORITY INC.
GANDER INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT AUTHORITY INC.
ST. JOHN’S INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT AUTHORITY
DEER LAKE REGIONAL AIRPORT AUTHORITY INC.
HALIFAX INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT AUTHORITHY
HAMILTON INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LIMITED
GREATER LONDON INTERNATIONAL AIRPORTS AUTHORITY
OTTAWA MACDONALD-CARTIER INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT AUTHORITY
SAULT STE. MARIE AIRPORT DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION
GREATER TORONTO AIRPORTS AUTHORITY
AÉROPORTS DE MONTRÉAL
AEROPORT INTERNATIONAL DE MONT TREMBLANT INC
AÉROPORT DE QUÉBEC INC.
REGINA AIRPORT AUTHORITY
SASKATOON AIRPORT AUTHORITY
NANAIMO AIRPORT COMMISSION
THOMPSON REGIONAL AIRPORT AUTHORITY
FREDERICTON INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT AUTHORITY
SAINT JOHN AIRPORT INC.
NORTHERN NEW BRUNSWICK AIRPORT AUTHORITY
J.A. DOUGLAS MCCURDY SYDNEY AIRPORT
SYDNEY AIRPORT AUTHORITY
YOUR QUICK GATEWAY (WINDSOR) INC.
CHARLOTTETOWN AIRPORT AUTHORITY INC.
Defendants
CONSENT ORDER
UPON motion by the Plaintiff to amend the Statement of claim dated March 25, 2019. in the form attached as Schedule “A” to the Plaintiff’s Notice of Motion dated August 5, 2020;
AND UPON motion by all of the Defendants, except Kamloops Airport Authority Society, Grande Prairie Airport Commission, and Thompson Regional Airport Authority (hereafter the “Moving Defendants”) for an order pursuant to Rule 221 of the Federal Courts Rules to strike out the Plaintiff’s Statement of Claim for not pleading a reasonable cause of action under the Competition Act, and also lack of subject-matter jurisdiction;
AND UPON considering all of the Defendants’ and the Plaintiff’s consent to the terms of this Order;
THIS COURT ORDERS that:
The Statement of Claim is hereby amended in the form attached as Schedule “A” to the Plaintiff’s Notice of Motion dated August 5, 2020 (the “Amended Statement of Claim”);
The Moving Defendants’ motion is granted;
The Plaintiff’s Amended Statement of Claim is struck against all Defendants pursuant to Rule 221(1)(a) as presently disclosing no reasonable cause of action under the Competition Act and for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction for the causes of action set out in the Amended Statement of Claim;
For greater certainty, this Order:
is not an adjudication on the merits of the Plaintiff’s claims; and
is without prejudice to the Plaintiff or any putative class member from continuing, refiling, filing, and/or recommencing any of the claims in the Statement of Claim or Amended Statement of Claim before a provincial superior court.
Pursuant to Rule 334.39, all parties to this action shall bear their own costs.
“Glennys L. McVeigh”
Judge