HEMSWORTH COLLETTE AND MICHAEL v. THE UNITED KINGDOM - 58559/09 - Chamber Judgment

This judgment will become final in the circumstances set out in Article 44 � 2 of the Convention. It may be subject to editorial revision.

The European Court of Human Rights (Fourth Section), sitting as a Chamber composed of:

��������� Ineta Ziemele, President, ��������� David Th�r Bj�rgvinsson, ��������� P�ivi Hirvel�, ��������� George Nicolaou, ��������� Zdravka Kalaydjieva, ��������� Vincent A. De Gaetano, ��������� Paul Mahoney, judges, and Fran�oise Elens-Passos , Section Registrar,

�(3) Where the circumstances of any death which has been, or is being, investigated by a coroner appear to the coroner to disclose that an offence may have been committed against the law of Northern Ireland or the law of any other country or territory, the coroner must as soon as practicable send to the Director a written report of the circumstances.

�... the confusion that has been created by the fragmented production of documents over the years. There has been duplication of some documents and a failure to produce certain documents on some occasions and then their production on other occasions. It has been acknowledged that the level of redactions have on occasions been excessive.�