Rights vs security & privacy
Individual Privacy or National Security: Which Matters More?
LNAT Section B · Model essay
The essay prompt
When the demands of personal privacy clash with the protection of the state and its citizens, which should carry greater weight? Take a clear position and defend it.
The stance
The question rests on a false binary: privacy and security are not rivals to be ranked but goods that mostly reinforce each other. Where they genuinely conflict, neither is categorically supreme; the deciding principle is proportionality, with privacy as the default and security-driven intrusion justified only when it is targeted, legally authorised and independently overseen.
The case for
Security is the precondition of every other right, including privacy
A state that cannot protect life cannot deliver privacy either; the right to life under Article 2 ECHR is the foundation on which the exercise of all other freedoms depends. Where intelligence prevents an atrocity, it preserves the very conditions in which privacy can be enjoyed. On this view, when the conflict is genuine and the threat grave, a proportionate intrusion on privacy is not the enemy of liberty but its guarantor.
The case against
Privacy is the structural check that prevents security powers from being abused
Treated as expendable, 'national security' becomes a self-justifying licence for executive overreach. The House of Lords struck down indefinite detention without trial in A v Secretary of State for the Home Department (2004), holding that even a public emergency could not justify a disproportionate and discriminatory measure. Privacy and its associated protections are precisely what force the state to demonstrate proportionality rather than assert necessity.
Elite unlocks every LNAT Section B model essay in full — the worked argument, steel-manned counters, verified authorities and the founder's own plan behind each one.
Sign up and unlockThe founder's own plan for this essay
The exact plan this essay was built from — the founder's working notes before the model answer was written.
Elite unlocks every LNAT Section B model essay in full — the worked argument, steel-manned counters, verified authorities and the founder's own plan behind each one.
Sign up and unlockGenerate a model essay from this plan
Turn this plan into a finished essay, instantly.
Elite turns the founder's plan into a complete, 500–600 word Section B model essay written to the structure above — a clear stance, distinct points, a steel-manned counter and a tight finish. Generate, read, regenerate.
Sign up and unlock