What is the ratio in Co-operative Insurance v Argyll Stores?

Courts will not grant specific performance to enforce positive contractual obligations that require constant judicial supervision to ensure compliance. Such orders would be oppressive and impractical.

What did the court decide in Co-operative Insurance v Argyll Stores?

The House of Lords refused to grant specific performance to compel Argyll to reopen and continue operating their supermarket, despite breaching a covenant to keep the store open.

Why is Co-operative Insurance v Argyll Stores important for contract law?

It reaffirmed the fundamental principle limiting specific performance and remains the leading authority on why courts refuse to order performance of positive obligations requiring ongoing supervision.

Premium Case

This case is available to Pro and Elite subscribers. Upgrade to access the full library of 500+ landmark cases.

Upgrade to Pro

← Back to Case Library

Premium Case

This case is available to Pro and Elite subscribers. Upgrade to access the full library of 500+ landmark cases.

Upgrade to Pro

← Back to Case Library